Surgeons performing a surgery on a patient in a hospital

Is your surgeon medically qualified?

You may want to re-consider having bunion surgery upon hearing that podiatric surgeons are in fact not medically qualified as doctors.

Andrew Robinson, Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon at Spire Cambridge Lea Hospital and former president of regulatory body the British Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (BOFAS), said: “Patients don’t understand that a consultant podiatric surgeon is not the same as a surgeon on the specialist register. The title itself is misleading.”

Orthopaedic surgeons, like all doctors, are registered with the General Medical Council, while podiatric surgeons are registered with the Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC).

Non-doctors have been able to operate on bunions since surgical podiatry was developed in Britain two decades ago, but within Europe, only Britain and Spain allow practitioners who are not registered doctors to undertake foot and ankle surgery.

71-year-old Joyce Dunbar from Norwich suffered at the hands of a surgeon who was not qualified as a doctor. She was left unable to walk unaided and in agony after her big toe was discovered to be fractured following a bunion operation. As a result, her foot has been irreparably damaged.

Mr Bob Sharp, a Consultant Orthopaedic surgeon for Oxford University Hospitals, explained that the risks associated with bunion surgery are considerable – there are approximately 200 different ways in which bunion surgery can be performed and 10% of patients who undergo the surgery end up worse off, with only 1 in 5 surgeries resolving the initial problem.

Joyce’s medical records were sent to Mr Sharp, who concluded that the fracture to Joyce’s toe was the result of a cut made in the wrong place, which he described as “a disaster”. The NHS Litigation Authority, acting for NHS Norfolk, denied this was the case and claimed it was a ‘stress fracture’ caused after the operation, which Mr Sharp disputed. He said: “The fracture has occurred in such a plane and is so straight that it is obvious it was made by a saw.”

It was only after a later operation that Joyce became aware of the fact that podiatric surgeons are in fact not surgeons at all. She said: “I had no idea the man operating on my foot was not a doctor; if I had, I’d have gone elsewhere.”

Ally Taft, partner with Medical Accident Group, said: “Joyce’s case highlights the need for the proper clinical governance that exists for doctors. Whilst that is unavailable, limitations of the treatments and the diagnoses that podiatric surgeons can offer should be made transparent to patients.”

If you’ve suffered from negligent treatment, contact our specialist team today, free on 0800 050 1668 or fill in the form below.

Surgeons performing a surgery on a patient in a hospital Surgeons performing a surgery on a patient in a hospital

More News Stories

orthopaedic doctor in their surgery treating a patient

Specialist in trauma and orthopaedic surgery suspended over treatment concerns

Read More
Doctor talking to and comforting patient at hospital

Spire Healthcare review of gynaecologist’s patients

Read More
Doctor speaking to patient about patient's concerns over unsafe independent cosmetic surgery in a doctors office

Concerns over unsafe independent cosmetic surgery services

Read More

Meet the Team

Ally Taft, Head of Clinical Negligence

Starting out as a physiotherapist, Ally embarked on her legal training knowing that she wanted to specialise in clinical negligence from the outset. Now a partner for Medical Accident Group, her experience and medical understanding have stood her and her clients in good stead, combined, as they are, with her determination to seek justice for clients whose lives have been devastated by clinical negligence.

Find Out More

Contact Us

Start your no obligation consultation now